Mephisto vs Birkenstock: Who Is Best?

Reading Time: 5 minutes is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure here.

Last Updated on April 2, 2023

Buying a new pair of shoes is a decision that needs a lot of thought.

It’s easy to jump at the lowest price, but this can sometimes lead you to opt for a pair that only lasts for a couple of weeks. No one wants to end up with broken shoes and painful feet!

Instead, it’s important to research your target brands to ensure you know what you’re buying. Research and reviews are great ways to work out whether you’re investing in a good shoe, or a shoe that’ll break after one wear. In this article, we’ll be taking a look at two leading retailers: Mephisto and Birkenstocks. Both brands are well known, but who measures up best?

If you’re ready for a new pair of shoes, keep reading. We’ve compared Mephisto and Birkenstocks to help you make your decision.

What Are The Key Differences Between Mephisto And Birkenstock?

Both Mephisto and Birkenstock have large followings and both offer popular shoes too, but what are the differences between these two brands? We’ve researched the most important differences to give you a quick look at how these two shoe retailers measure up at a glance.

Here’s a quick look at the key differences:

  • Mephisto offers sandals in brighter colors than Birkenstock.
  • Birkenstock is a more well-known brand that’s been featured on fashion week runways.
  • Both brands offer sandals, but Mephisto has a larger general shoe range.
  • Birkenstock offers more sandal variations.
  • Mephisto has more women’s options for formal events (such as dress shoes and heels).
  • Mephisto also offers more outdoor/active shoes.

These are the surface differences, but once you start investigating both brands you’ll see the situation is more complex! This is a quick summary, but let’s get into the nitty-gritty. Keep reading for a direct comparison of these two shoe brands.

Scroll down for more.

Which Brand Is Best?

Here’s a comprehensive comparison of Birkenstock vs. Mephisto to help you decide on your next purchase.

Brand Recognition

– Mephisto: Mephisto was established in 1965 and the brand is relatively well-known, however, it hasn’t managed to break onto the fashion scene. The shoe brand also lacks a heavy social media presence, this indicates that they’re not fashion-focused.

– Birkenstock: Birkenstock is an extremely well-known shoe brand and their sandals can be spotted easily. They regularly collaborate with celebrities and fashion designers too. Whether you’ve bought a pair before or not, you’ll recognise the classic Birkenstock silhouette.

– Winner of this category: Birkenstock

Try Tower London discount code to buy Birkenstock

Range of Footwear

– Mephisto: When it comes to range, Mephisto has a large selection. From sneakers to boots, or ballet flats to outdoor shoes, this brand is committed to offering a range. They offer both men’s and women’s options too. This is perfect for any buyer that hasn’t made their mind up yet.

– Birkenstock: Though Birkenstock offers different types of shoes, they mainly focus on their sandal collection. This brand is well known for its iconic sandals and they rarely stray from this silhouette. You can buy men’s and children’s shoes though.

– Winner of this category: Mephisto

Try the Mephisto Karin sneaker here.


– Mephisto: The Mephisto style and aesthetic vary depending on the type of shoe you’re buying. This brand offers feminine ballet flats and durable outdoors boots. When you shop here you have a lot of choices when it comes to style. They also offer a lot of different colors – from neutrals to bright pops of color there’s a shoe for all tastes.

– Birkenstock: Birkenstock tends to stick to their popular aesthetic. While they don’t stray from their typical design identity, you can find sandals in different colors and materials – but they do have the same overall aesthetic.

– Winner of this category: Mephisto

Try the Emilie ballet flat from Mephisto here.

The Fit and Comfort

– Mephisto: When designing their shoes, Mephisto always puts their fit and comfort first. These shoes often use high-quality textiles and leathers, plus they have ergonomic instep designs to support your Achilles tendon. Even their sandals and ballet flats offer a chunky sole, this is great for support – but some might not like the style.

– Birkenstock: Birkenstock also ensures its wearers are comfortable. This brand focuses on comfort with their cork-latex footbeds. These footbeds support your feet and posture, allowing you to walk well and feel comfortable at the same time. Birkenstock has been using this technology for decades – proving it’s a success. Not only that, but their shoes are ergonomic yet look sophisticated too.

– Winner of this category: Birkenstock

Try Birkenstock platform sandals here.


– Mephisto: Mephisto shoes are built for wear. With full-grain leathers and foot support, these shoes are able to survive outdoors activities and day-to-day movement too. Their most durable shoes are their walking boot ranges, but their sandals are also designed to last.

– Birkenstock: While sandals aren’t usually as robust as other shoe silhouettes, Birkenstock specializes in making sandals that stand the test of time. This brand has been in the business for decades and their premium leather sandals are long-lasting and designed to be used for decades.

– Winner of this category: Birkenstock

Try Birkenstock Arizona sandals in Marygold here.


– Mephisto: Mephisto shoes are priced at a medium-high point ($140 for a pair of sandals). While this is higher than other brands, the shoes are certain to be in good condition for a while. However, since this brand isn’t fashion-focused they might slip out of style sooner.

– Birkenstock: Birkenstock Offers sandals from $65-$140 putting them at a lower price than Mephisto. These sandals last for decades, plus Birkenstock has cemented itself as a fashionable brand. This means their iconic style will always be recognizable, adding value to your shoes. If you like brands or fashion, Birkenstock and its legacy will offer you better value for money.

– Winner of this category: Birkenstock

Try the Birkenstock Gizeh sandal here and read my Birkenstock Gizeh Review too.

Which Brand Wins?

Though Mephisto and Birkenstock are both great shoe designers, there can only be one winner!

We think Birkenstock offers premium design and durability for a great price. If you’re looking for a sandal or shoe that will last the test of time whilst still looking stylish, this is the brand to go for. Birkenstocks are known for their signature look and high-quality materials, so as long as you take care of the leather, this shoe will be at your side for years.

On the other hand, Mephisto is still a strong competitor – especially because they offer a wider range of shoes than Birkenstock. If you don’t mind that the brand isn’t as well known, Mephisto is worth a look. From walking boots to sneakers, Mephisto has a range of shoes that are crafted well.

Buying a new pair of shoes will always need some thought. Hopefully, this summary of Mephisto v.s. Birkenstock has inspired you! Whether you choose some classic Birkenstock sandals or some modern Mephisto boots, always research reviews and comparisons before buying.

What do you think of these brands? Do you have a favorite? Let us know in the comments!


Birkenstock vs Viking Sandals: Fashion Or Functionality, We Decide

A Comprehensive Review of the Birkenstock Madrid Sandal

Birkenstock Birko Flor vs Leather (Which Should You Choose?)

4 Brands That Give Birkenstock a Run for Their Money